Tuesday, June 17, 2008

More Suthun Hehatige

From Wonkette:

Oh, Texas Republicans, you are always so funny. Here is a fun button worn by everyone at the Texas GOP convention. When not making hilarious rape jokes, Texas Republicans like to make jokes about ambitious coloreds.
How many more months am I going to keep finding obnoxious shit like this while simultaneously hearing about nonsensical "post-racialism"????

Thursday, June 12, 2008

My Take on Boumediene

Ok. While I should be going home to clean my apartment, the temptation is just too great to write this now.

As I mentioned before, the opinion is over 130 pages. I'm not about to hash through it bit by bit, but I will address Scalia's dissent, already being fully embraced by the Right.

From the beginning, our beloved "Nino" distorts the entire concept of the case. Several times throughout his venomous dissent, he refers to the "war" against "radical Islamists" and various attacks the U.S. has suffered at the hands of Muslims: the Khobar Towers attack in Dharan, the embassy attacks at Dar es Salaam and Nairobi, the USS Cole and...the Marine barracks in Lebanon? (For my younger readers, that was an attack near the beginning of the Reagan administration.) Er, one of these things is not like the others...

Conflated responsibility for attacks aside, the fact is that the "War on Terror" is a war on an abstraction--it is a policy catch-phrase that, outside of an actual battlefield, serves only as rhetoric and a rationalization for the growth of the security state and reckless foreign policy. Not dissimilarly, it is no more a "war" than the war on illicit commodities, also known as the "War on Drugs." Certainly, there are tangible and substantial costs of blood and treasure for the victims and perpetrators of both of these "wars"--but neither is a war in any real sense.

9/11 wasn't an act of war--it was a heinous crime. 20 men, mostly Saudis, stole airplanes and murdered over 3,000 people. The Right has been all-too-quick to assign war powers to a president and Congress when, in fact, most of the acts they site are of a criminal nature. A "war on terror" would have to include a war on the Timothy McVeighs of the world, whom--by virtue of citizenship--are afforded constitutional protections and given trials. But this case doesn't even involve proper trials; it concerns whether or not foreign citizens--not to be confused with POWs--may challenge their incarceration in federal courts. Boumediene is one of several men who were imprisoned in Bosnia, by Bosnian authorities, held without charge, and then released for lack of evidence. After their release, they were picked up by Bosnian officials and transferred into U.S. custody--six years ago.

These men were not captured on the battlefield. These men were not, as far as anyone can tell, caught in the middle of some dastardly plot against the United States. Indeed, there is no evidence that, even if they are criminals, they had any intention of doing harm to the United States whatsoever. How they (legally speaking) came into the custody of the U.S. Military is quite a mystery to me. And, due to the legal black hole they found themselves in, as neither U.S. citizens or proper POWs (protected by the Geneva Conventions), they had no sufficient legal recourse to challenge their detentions.

Those whom have not followed this case closely may not be aware that Boumediene v. Bush had actually been denied certiorari before it was granted. (background here.) The testimony of a high-ranking military lawyer, Lt. Col. Stephen Abraham, has been speculated to have changed the mind of Justice Anthony Kennedy to grant cert, as he testified that the CSRTs were, for all intents and purposes, worthless--thus nullifying the substantive and procedural due process the CSRTs were designed to provide. (I'll find the link later. kind of in a hurry at the moment.) Abraham link here.

The Right is howling as if this is the end to military justice as we know it. In reality, the Boumediene decision safeguards the rights of people whom have been held (and in several cases, tortured) for years without any sort of legal justification as to why...and thus rebukes the attempts of the government to overstep its prerogative yet again. I'm all for being tough on terrorists, but not at the expense of a cornerstone of personal liberty by an over-reaching collusive alliance of the Legislative and Executive branches of the federal government.

Way to go, SCOTUS.



Boumediene v. Bush: The Result

In what is undoubtedly a victory for freedom, the Supreme Court handed down a 5-4 decision granting habeas rights to detainees at Guantanamo.

I'm reading the a 130+ page decision right now, but it looks good so far. I'll write more after I've read it fully, but it seems that the legal black hole the administration created for detainees has been effectively destroyed...and that is a very good thing.

Best quote so far:

In considering both the procedural and substantive standards used to impose detention to prevent acts of terrorism, the courts must accord proper deference to the political branches. However, security subsists, too, in fidelity to freedom's first principles, chief among them being freedom from arbitrary and unlawful restraint and the personal liberty that is secured by adherence to the separation of powers.

Monday, June 9, 2008

Friday, June 6, 2008

Hatethought?

So, while I am not the movie fan I used to be--basically because I lack the free time to go see them these days-- I wanted to go see Adam Sandler's Don't Mess with the Zohan. Sure, it's bound to be juvenile and silly--that's kind of his thing. But one reviewer over at WaPo doesn't seem amused:
In the world according to Adam, Arabs are childish, violent, stupid; Israelis are aggressive, mendacious, oversexed; white Americans are gun-crazed, violent rednecks or smarmy aristocratic businessmen/gangsters; post-menopausal women are riven with lust. And all this hatethought is expressed in support of a political argument that's no more sophisticated than "Can't we just all get along?"
I haven't yet seen the movie--and it very well may suck--but this little diatribe isn't about to stop me from seeing it. Anyone who has ever seen a Sandler film knows that the characters are always exaggerated, stereotypical, and crude. That's what makes them funny.

And before you ask "What if he was doing that to black people? Would you still be as forgiving?," I'll give you two words: Soul Plane.

Without debating the merits of the film or Sandler's value as an "artist," he is clearly a satirical absurdist. The preview shows an array of ridiculously impossible feats (and feet) that only highlights the unreality of the film's setting. This isn't a movie promoting hatred in any way--save, perhaps, for the sheer banality of Hollywood film making.

So, Mr. Stephen Hunter, lighten up. Just because you don't find someone funny, it is irresponsible to accuse him of 'hate'--and even more so make up the word "hatethought" to express it.

Wednesday, June 4, 2008

(Maybe) We Can!



So, the day has finally come.

As a libertarian/fiscal conservative, I can't say I'm particularly pleased with Barack Obama's domestic policies, to be mild. Furthermore, I am greatly concerned about the enlarged role of the Executive branch in American government and do not want some messianic political force to occupy its head and increase its already bloated capacity.

That said, I am absolutely thrilled that Barack Obama won the Democratic nomination. And yes, it's because I'm black.

The reason is simple: as absurd as the idea is that parents tell their children they can grow up to be whatever they want (regardless of their abilty)--even President of the United States--such an idea has been an almost laughable fantasy to black children. No matter how smart, how gifted, or how popular any black person could be, he/she would always be black and therefore automatically disqualified for leadership of their own country. No one said it, but it never needed to be.

Thus, to a black person, race has forever been an inherently limiting factor to how much he or she can even hope to succeed--because their native country judges them, collectively, as less-than-worthy.

To illustrate my point, I am reminded of one class I took in college. A fellow black classmate said in open discussion that he didn't know he could go to college until he was a sophomore in high school. He was an obviously bright and thoughtful young man, but had to be told in his teen years that college was an option for him--he didn't think he was 'college material'. He is the black America that needs someone like Obama--that stand as a testament that a black person can succeed to become (for better or worse, given the aforementioned state of the Executive) the most powerful individual on Earth--and be elected to it. Personal achievement will not come so long as a group of individuals feel limited before they even get out of the gate.

Will Obama's nomination or election solve the problems of the black underclass, or even the continued prejudice experienced by the black middle class? No. But legitimate proof that a black man can overcome the prevelant view of his race lessens the subtle, but very real, limitations black people feel. Children of all races may grow up for the next 4-8 years with a black man as the foremost representative of their country. If that happens, and Obama carries himself and governs his office in an effective, judicious, and positive way, many people may grow up admiring him and thereby decrease the negative perceptions of black people as a collective, rather than judging us individually.

I understand that this hope is far-fetched and idealistic--but if you were to tell my 80 year old father he'd live to see a black nominee on a major party ticket when he was my age, he's have laughed at you--considering that the Voting Rights Act wouldn't be signed for another half-decade. Far-fetched and idealistic is pretty much all we've ever had. (Notice, such an outlook also applies to libertarians.)

So, while there is plenty to fear from an Obama presidency, I can say right now that I am very proud of him for what he has been able to do. I hope he 'does us proud'--in spite of the fact that, in all probability, an Obama presidency will largely be a disappointment.


Monday, June 2, 2008

Bo Diddley, R.I.P.

For my Mood Music Monday, I thought I'd just play a little ditty from the late Bo Diddley: